Skip to main content
SFU Health and Counselling Services
Registered Clinical Counsellor

A photo of money on fire
Jp Valery
Knowing why you’re doing something, and feeling that what you’re doing is therefore meaningful

Money is a terrible motivator.

If I were to say to you, “Reader, I’d like you to come up with a creative way of solving this problem we have,” or “I’d like you to complete this complex task requiring somewhat sophisticated cognitive abilities,” you’d actually perform worse if I offered you a nice chunk of change as a reward.

Seem backwards? It should, because we’re quite conditioned to think about motivation in terms of linear, easily explainable rewards and punishments (see what I did there?).

Classical and operant conditioning form the bedrock of behavioural psychology, and between them explain a whole lot about motivation and learning. Classical conditioning, most widely known by the famous “Pavlov’s dog” example, tells us that we can create a new response to a stimulus merely by pairing that stimulus with another one a whole bunch of times. As a result, we can train dogs to salivate at the sound of a bell by ringing a bell every time we give them food for a few weeks.

Meanwhile, Skinner’s operant conditioning explains motivation in terms of reward and punishment. If I want to create more of a certain behaviour, I should therefore offer a reward after every instance of that behaviour, reinforcing it. Similarly, if I want to decrease the frequency of a behaviour I can pair it with a punishment, which by all reasonable logic should decrease and hopefully extinguish the behaviour in question.

A good knowledge of these basic theories of behavioural psychology allows us to do some pretty amazing things: train animals, explain and treat phobias, make all sorts of laboratory rats do all sorts of crazy things, and the list goes on.

But when it comes to human motivation, the aforementioned theories are about as helpful as an umbrella in a snowstorm. People try to use them, but they don’t really end up accomplishing useful.

A photo of a woman using an umbrella while it is snowing

At least, this is what I learned when I participated a few days ago in a webinar by Daniel Pink, bestselling author of the book Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us (not to mention one of my favourite-ever career books – The Adventures of Johnny Bunko).

Pink talked for about an hour about his book and the decades of motivation research that he delved into to write it. The webinar itself was divided into two main topics: why our thinking about motivation is upside down; and what people and organizations can do to increase motivation as a result.

The thrust of the former statement goes something like this: Money only effectively motivates us in the performance of simple, mechanical tasks requiring little cognitive activity. So, if I was assembling something rudimentary on a production line, or stuffing envelopes, or something similar, larger monetary rewards would indeed give me motivation to work harder and be more productive. But when we’re asked to perform tasks requiring even rudimentary cognitive abilities, it turns out that money doesn’t really motivate us at all. In fact, it can even decrease our motivation.

So what motivates us to perform better at complex tasks? Pink gave three answers: autonomy, mastery, and purpose. Self-direction (autonomy) naturally increases intrinsic motivation, as does the feeling that you actually know what you’re doing and that you can do it well (mastery). Most motivating of all, though? Knowing why you’re doing something, and feeling that what you’re doing is therefore meaningful (purpose).

To put these three findings about motivation into practice, Pink suggested some pretty neat resources and tips. The first is a kind of autonomy self-assessment: from 1-10, how much control do you have over 1) what you do, 2) how you do it, 3) when and where you do it, and 4) who you do it with? If you add up the numbers and the total is less than 27, Pink says that you’re in trouble. Similarly, if you score high in some areas but disproportionately low in one, you’re not doing well enough.

Other ideas to increase autonomy (that are currently being used by real companies) include what Pink termed “Fedex days”: entire days where employees can work on anything they want, and then they present their ideas and work to the team the next day (Why Fedex days?  Employees have to “deliver overnight”). Alternatively, companies can have regular Genius Hours, wherein employees can work on whatever they want, however they want, for that hour.

On the topic of purpose, Pink suggested doing a quick feedback activity on why activities are being done, or why companies even exist. This could involve having employees write on a cue card what they believe the mission of their company, department, etc. actually is. If you get a bunch of blank cards, you know you’re in trouble.

Ultimately, Pink only scratched the surface of the work he’s done studying and writing about motivation. For anyone who’s interested in learning more, I’d strongly encourage reading his book.

SFU Health and Counselling Services
Registered Clinical Counsellor
David Lindskoog is a Registered Clinical Counsellor at Health & Counselling who used to work as a Career Advisor with Career Services. David is passionate about suicide prevention, social justice, career and professional development concerns, and the use of role-playing games in therapy. Check out his group: Dungeons & Worry Dragons. While you're here, check out Dave's Diary! It is an ongoing series of journal entries touching on various aspects related to careers and well-being. Want to hear Dave's thoughts on a particular topic?  Send him an email, and he'll do his best to include it in his next post!  
visibility  75
Nov 12, 2011

You Might Like These... During the Work Term, Professional Development, Workplace Success, Workplace Transition, Communication

Co-op coordinator wth student during site visit
Make the Most of Your Co-op Site Visits

Your Co-op Coordinator, supervisor, and you in the same room -- time for a site visit! Co-op site visits are a time for reflection on your work term including what could be improved and what has been great so far.

person with their head in a book
Responsibility and Success

One of the most memorable parts of my time in co-op was the collection of accidents, errors, mistakes, and mix-ups that happened in the course of working in the laboratory.


A woman fast asleep
Sleeping for Success at Work!

The days of pulling all nighters and getting by on 2-3 hours sleep are over! Getting enough sleep is essential to ensure you can keep up with the demands of a fulltime work schedule and put forth your best performance.

You Might Like These... Co-op Reflections

R to L: Corinna Bjornson Board President, Dixon Society Nicole Skuce Resource Development Coordinator, Adele Wilson Executive Director, VanCity Representative, accept a $10,000 community action grant from VanCity.
English Alumnus Finds Work in Social Development Through SFU Co-op

Nicole Skuce, Arts and Social Sciences Co-op alumnus, was able to use her networking skills to turn one of her Co-op work terms into a career. Read on to discover how she effectively used her time at SFU as a stepping stone to her current position.

Laptop on table next to copper mug, surrounded by string lights
Supporting Students (and Myself) during the Pandemic while on Co-op at SFU Health & Counselling

Searching for Co-op and wondering what it’s like working for SFU? How about working for SFU Health & Counselling (SFU HCS) during the pandemic? Read as Christy recounts her Co-op experience at SFU HCS and how it has helped her enhance well-being while helping other students.

David and his dad on the beach
Advice From My Dad - Make Yourself Irreplaceable | Part Two

"Make yourself irreplaceable," he would say, regaling stories of his own young employment at a car dealership. "Take the shifts that nobody else wants, work extra hours whenever possible, be the guy that your boss knows they can always count on." Was this really what my dad wanted me to do with my life?